Restaurant Server Performance Review Examples: Dominate Your Review

Ready to ace your performance review? This isn’t just another article filled with generic advice. This is a Restaurant Server-specific guide to crafting a performance review narrative that showcases your value and sets you up for your next raise or promotion. You’ll walk away with concrete examples, scripts, and a framework to translate your daily contributions into quantifiable achievements.

What you’ll walk away with

• Rewrite 5 performance review bullets using a rubric that prioritizes impact and metrics.
• Craft a “brag document” outline to capture your wins throughout the year, making review time a breeze.
• Use a negotiation script to advocate for a higher rating or desired outcome.
• Identify and reframe 3 common Restaurant Server weaknesses into areas of growth and improvement.
• Build a 30-day proof plan to demonstrate progress on a chosen development area.
• Master the art of the STAR method with tailored examples for Restaurant Server scenarios.
• A checklist for preparing for the performance review.

What this is and isn’t

• This is: A practical guide to showcasing your accomplishments and addressing areas for growth in your restaurant server performance review.
• This isn’t: A generic guide to performance reviews.

The Restaurant Server’s Mission: Guest Satisfaction & Efficiency

A Restaurant Server exists to ensure guest satisfaction and efficient service while maximizing table turnover and minimizing errors. That means balancing attentiveness, accuracy, and speed, all while maintaining a positive attitude.

What a hiring manager scans for in 15 seconds

Hiring managers are looking for specific examples of your ability to handle pressure, provide excellent customer service, and contribute to the restaurant’s profitability. They want to see evidence of problem-solving skills, teamwork, and a commitment to continuous improvement.

• Positive customer feedback: Indicates excellent service and rapport-building skills.
• Up-selling success: Shows initiative and sales acumen.
• Error reduction: Demonstrates attention to detail and commitment to accuracy.
• Teamwork examples: Highlights collaboration and a willingness to support colleagues.
• Problem-solving stories: Reveals resourcefulness and the ability to handle difficult situations.

The mistake that quietly kills candidates

The biggest mistake is providing generic statements without specific examples or metrics. Saying you’re “good with customers” doesn’t mean anything. You need to show *how* you’re good with customers and what the impact was.

Use this to rephrase a weak statement.

Weak: Provided excellent customer service.

Strong: Resolved a customer complaint regarding a delayed order by offering a complimentary appetizer, resulting in positive feedback and a return visit.

Building Your Brag Document: Capture Your Wins

A brag document is a running log of your accomplishments, big and small, throughout the year. This makes performance review time far less stressful and ensures you don’t forget any of your contributions.

Here’s what to include in your brag document:

• Specific examples of excellent customer service: Include details of the situation, your actions, and the outcome.
• Instances of up-selling or cross-selling: Quantify the impact on revenue.
• Solutions to problems: Describe the challenge, your approach, and the resolution.
• Positive feedback from customers or colleagues: Save emails, notes, or screenshots.
• Contributions to team goals: Highlight your role in achieving shared objectives.

Using the STAR Method: Structure Your Stories

The STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) is a powerful way to structure your performance review narratives. It helps you provide clear, concise, and compelling examples of your skills and accomplishments.

Here’s how it works:

• Situation: Describe the context of the situation.
• Task: Explain the task or challenge you faced.
• Action: Detail the specific actions you took.
• Result: Highlight the outcome of your actions and quantify the impact whenever possible.

STAR Example: Handling a Customer Complaint

Situation: A customer in a busy Italian restaurant received the wrong entree and was visibly upset.

Task: My task was to resolve the customer’s complaint quickly and efficiently to ensure they had a positive dining experience.

Action: I immediately apologized for the mistake, offered to replace the entree with the correct dish, and provided a complimentary glass of wine while they waited. I also informed the manager and kitchen staff of the error to prevent similar issues in the future.

Result: The customer was satisfied with the resolution and thanked me for my prompt and courteous service. They left a positive review online, praising the restaurant’s customer service.

Addressing Weaknesses: Frame Them as Growth Opportunities

Everyone has areas for improvement. The key is to acknowledge your weaknesses honestly and demonstrate a commitment to growth.

Here are some common Restaurant Server weaknesses and how to reframe them:

• Weakness: Difficulty remembering complex orders.
  Reframe: Developing strategies to improve order accuracy and memory, such as using a notepad and repeating orders back to customers.
• Weakness: Hesitation up-selling.
  Reframe: Working on building confidence and knowledge of menu items to effectively suggest add-ons to customers.
• Weakness: Time management during peak hours.
  Reframe: Implementing techniques to prioritize tasks and manage time more efficiently during busy periods.

Use this 30-day plan to improve your upselling skills.

30-Day Proof Plan: Upselling Skills

• Week 1: Study the menu and identify potential upselling opportunities for each dish.
• Week 2: Practice upselling techniques with colleagues during slow periods.
• Week 3: Track upselling success with a personal log.
• Week 4: Review results and identify areas for further improvement.

Performance Review Checklist: Be Prepared

Preparation is key to a successful performance review. Use this checklist to ensure you’re ready to showcase your accomplishments and discuss your goals.

• Review your job description and identify key responsibilities.
• Gather your brag document and identify key accomplishments.
• Prepare specific examples using the STAR method.
• Identify areas for improvement and develop a plan for growth.
• Practice your talking points and anticipate potential questions.
• Dress professionally and arrive on time.
• Be prepared to discuss your goals for the future.

Negotiation Script: Advocate for Yourself

Don’t be afraid to advocate for yourself during your performance review. If you believe you deserve a higher rating or a specific outcome, be prepared to make your case.

Use this when requesting a higher rating.

“I appreciate the feedback and understand the areas where I can improve. However, I also believe that my accomplishments this year, particularly [mention a specific achievement with metrics], demonstrate that I consistently exceed expectations. I am confident that I can continue to contribute significantly to the team’s success, and I believe a rating of [desired rating] would be a more accurate reflection of my performance.”

Language Bank: Phrases that Impress

Using the right language can make a big difference in how your performance is perceived. Here are some phrases that will help you showcase your value and professionalism.

• “I consistently exceeded customer expectations by…”
• “I implemented a new strategy that resulted in…”
• “I proactively identified and resolved a problem that saved the restaurant…”
• “I collaborated with my colleagues to achieve a team goal of…”
• “I am committed to continuous improvement and have developed a plan to address…”

Quiet Red Flags: What to Avoid

There are certain phrases and behaviors that can raise red flags during a performance review. Avoid these at all costs.

• Blaming others for your mistakes.
• Making excuses for poor performance.
• Being defensive or argumentative.
• Failing to take ownership of your development.
• Providing generic statements without specific examples.

FAQ

How do I prepare for a performance review as a Restaurant Server?

Preparation is key. Review your job description, document your accomplishments throughout the year (brag document), and prepare specific examples using the STAR method. Identify areas for improvement and develop a plan for growth. Practice your talking points and anticipate potential questions.

What if I disagree with my performance review?

It’s important to remain professional and respectful. Explain your perspective calmly and provide specific examples to support your claims. If you’re still not satisfied, consider discussing your concerns with your manager or HR department.

How can I demonstrate my commitment to continuous improvement?

Develop a plan for growth that includes specific goals, timelines, and metrics. Seek out opportunities for training and development. Ask for feedback from your manager and colleagues. Track your progress and share your successes with others.

What are some common mistakes to avoid during a performance review?

Avoid blaming others, making excuses, being defensive, failing to take ownership, and providing generic statements. Be prepared to discuss your accomplishments and areas for improvement with specific examples and a positive attitude.

How do I handle negative feedback during a performance review?

Listen carefully and try to understand the feedback. Ask clarifying questions and acknowledge the validity of the concerns. Express your commitment to improving and develop a plan to address the issues. Thank your manager for the feedback and follow up to demonstrate your progress.

What if I haven’t achieved all of my goals for the year?

Be honest about the challenges you faced and explain why you weren’t able to achieve your goals. Highlight the progress you made and the lessons you learned. Focus on what you can do differently in the future to achieve your goals.

How do I ask for a raise during my performance review?

Research industry standards for Restaurant Server salaries in your area. Highlight your accomplishments and the value you bring to the restaurant. Explain why you believe you deserve a raise and provide specific examples to support your request. Be prepared to negotiate and be realistic about your expectations.

What are some skills that are important for a Restaurant Server?

Customer service, communication, teamwork, problem-solving, time management, and attention to detail are all essential skills for a Restaurant Server. Demonstrate these skills in your performance review by providing specific examples of how you have used them to achieve success.

What’s the best way to document my achievements throughout the year?

Create a brag document and update it regularly. Include specific examples of your accomplishments, positive feedback from customers and colleagues, and solutions to problems. This will make performance review time much easier and ensure you don’t forget any of your contributions.

How can I improve my upselling skills?

Study the menu and identify potential upselling opportunities for each dish. Practice upselling techniques with colleagues during slow periods. Track your upselling success and review your results to identify areas for further improvement. Offer personalized recommendations based on customer preferences.

How can I improve my time management skills during peak hours?

Prioritize tasks, delegate responsibilities, and streamline your workflow. Use a notepad to keep track of orders and customer requests. Minimize distractions and focus on the task at hand. Ask for help from your colleagues when needed.

What should I wear to my performance review?

Dress professionally and appropriately for the restaurant’s dress code. This shows that you take the review seriously and respect your manager’s time. Avoid wearing anything too casual or revealing.

How do I follow up after my performance review?

Thank your manager for their time and feedback. Express your commitment to improving and ask for support in achieving your goals. Follow up with a written summary of the key takeaways from the review and your plan for growth. Schedule regular check-ins with your manager to track your progress.

---

More Restaurant Server resources

Browse more posts and templates for Restaurant Server: Restaurant Server