Red Flags in Hairdresser Interviews: Spotting the Fakers

Hiring a Hairdresser is like finding the perfect cut – you need someone skilled, reliable, and able to handle the pressure. But how do you separate the true artists from the stylists who are all talk and no transformation? This article gives you the insider knowledge to identify red flags in hairdresser interviews, ensuring you hire someone who can deliver stunning results, not just empty promises.

By the end of this, you’ll have a checklist of red flags to watch out for, a set of probing questions to expose weak candidates, and a framework to assess their technical skills and customer service. This isn’t about finding someone who ticks all the boxes; it’s about identifying potential problems before they ruin your salon’s reputation.

What You’ll Walk Away With

• A red flag checklist: 15+ warning signs to identify unreliable or underqualified hairdressers during the interview process.
• A probing question bank: Key questions designed to uncover hidden weaknesses in candidates’ experience and skills.
• A technical skill assessment framework: A method for evaluating a candidate’s practical skills, including cutting, coloring, and styling techniques.
• A customer service evaluation guide: A set of criteria for assessing a candidate’s ability to handle clients and build rapport.
• A decision matrix for evaluating candidates: A tool to compare and rank candidates based on their strengths and weaknesses.
• A plan to improve your hiring strategy: Actionable steps to refine your recruitment process and attract top talent.

What This Is and What It Isn’t

• This is: A guide to spotting potential problems during hairdresser interviews.
• This isn’t: A general guide to hiring employees.

What a Hiring Manager Scans for in 15 Seconds

Hiring managers quickly scan for evidence of real-world experience and technical expertise. They look for specific skills, client success stories, and a passion for the craft.

• Technical proficiency: Can they describe their techniques with confidence and precision?
• Customer service skills: Do they have a track record of building rapport with clients?
• Problem-solving ability: Can they handle unexpected challenges with grace and efficiency?
• Adaptability: Are they willing to learn new techniques and adapt to changing trends?
• Professionalism: Do they present themselves in a polished and respectful manner?

The Mistake That Quietly Kills Candidates

The biggest mistake is providing generic answers without specific examples. Hiring managers want to hear about real-world situations where the candidate demonstrated their skills and problem-solving abilities.

Use this to replace a generic answer with a specific example.

Weak: “I’m a great communicator.”
Strong: “I once had a client who was unhappy with their color. I listened to their concerns, explained the process, and adjusted the formula to achieve the desired result. They were so happy with the outcome that they became a regular client.”

Red Flag #1: Vague Answers and Lack of Specifics

A candidate who can’t provide concrete examples of their work is a major red flag. They might be exaggerating their experience or lacking the technical skills to back up their claims.

Probing Question: “Tell me about a time you had to correct a color gone wrong. What steps did you take, and what was the outcome?”

Red Flag #2: Bad-Mouthing Previous Employers or Clients

A candidate who speaks negatively about their previous employers or clients is likely to bring that negativity to your salon. This is a sign of poor professionalism and a lack of respect.

Instead: Look for candidates who focus on the positive aspects of their previous experiences and demonstrate a willingness to learn from their mistakes.

Red Flag #3: Inability to Describe Technical Skills in Detail

A hairdresser who can’t explain their techniques with confidence and precision likely lacks the necessary technical skills. This is especially concerning for specialized services like coloring or extensions.

Probing Question: “Can you walk me through your process for creating a balayage? What factors do you consider when choosing the right colors and placement?”

Red Flag #4: Lack of Passion for Hairdressing

A hairdresser who doesn’t express genuine enthusiasm for their craft is unlikely to provide exceptional service. Passion is essential for staying up-to-date on trends and delivering personalized results.

Instead: Look for candidates who are actively involved in the hairdressing community, attend workshops and seminars, and demonstrate a commitment to continuous learning.

Red Flag #5: Unprofessional Appearance or Demeanor

A hairdresser who presents themselves in an unprofessional manner is unlikely to make a good impression on clients. This includes sloppy attire, poor hygiene, and a lack of respect for salon policies.

Instead: Look for candidates who are well-groomed, dressed appropriately, and demonstrate a professional attitude.

Red Flag #6: Ignoring or Dismissing Client Concerns

A hairdresser who doesn’t listen to or dismisses client concerns is a recipe for disaster. Customer service is paramount in the hairdressing industry, and a lack of empathy can lead to unhappy clients and negative reviews.

Probing Question: “Tell me about a time you had a difficult client. How did you handle the situation, and what was the outcome?”

Red Flag #7: Overpromising and Underdelivering

A hairdresser who makes unrealistic promises to clients is setting themselves up for failure. Honesty and transparency are essential for building trust and managing expectations.

Instead: Look for candidates who provide realistic assessments of what they can achieve and are upfront about any limitations.

Red Flag #8: Reluctance to Learn New Techniques

A hairdresser who is unwilling to learn new techniques is likely to become stagnant and outdated. The hairdressing industry is constantly evolving, and a commitment to continuous learning is essential for staying competitive.

Probing Question: “What new techniques or trends are you currently exploring? How do you stay up-to-date on the latest developments in the industry?”Red Flag #9: Lack of Knowledge About Hair Products

A hairdresser who is unfamiliar with hair products or unable to recommend appropriate products to clients is a major red flag. Product knowledge is essential for providing personalized recommendations and achieving optimal results.

Instead: Look for candidates who are knowledgeable about a wide range of hair products and can explain the benefits of each product to clients.

Red Flag #10: Inability to Handle Criticism

A hairdresser who is unable to handle criticism is unlikely to improve their skills or adapt to feedback. Constructive criticism is essential for growth and development in any profession.

Instead: Look for candidates who are open to feedback and demonstrate a willingness to learn from their mistakes.

Red Flag #11: Lack of Attention to Detail

A hairdresser who lacks attention to detail is likely to make mistakes that can damage a client’s hair or ruin their style. Precision and accuracy are essential for achieving optimal results.

Instead: Look for candidates who are meticulous, organized, and demonstrate a commitment to precision.

Red Flag #12: Poor Time Management Skills

A hairdresser who struggles with time management is likely to run late, double-book appointments, or rush through services. This can lead to unhappy clients and a chaotic salon environment.

Instead: Look for candidates who are organized, efficient, and able to manage their time effectively.

Red Flag #13: Inability to Work Independently

A hairdresser who is unable to work independently is likely to require constant supervision and support. This can be a drain on salon resources and limit their ability to contribute to the team.

Instead: Look for candidates who are self-motivated, resourceful, and able to work independently with minimal supervision.

Red Flag #14: Failure to Follow Salon Policies and Procedures

A hairdresser who disregards salon policies and procedures is likely to create conflict and disrupt the salon environment. Compliance is essential for maintaining a safe, professional, and consistent service.

Instead: Look for candidates who demonstrate a willingness to follow rules and regulations and respect the established salon culture.

Red Flag #15: Unrealistic Salary Expectations

A hairdresser who has unrealistic salary expectations may be out of touch with the market or overestimating their value. This can lead to dissatisfaction and turnover down the line.

Instead: Research the average salary for hairdressers in your area and be prepared to negotiate a fair and competitive compensation package.

FAQ

What are the most important qualities to look for in a hairdresser?

Technical proficiency, customer service skills, passion for hairdressing, and professionalism are essential. Look for candidates who can demonstrate these qualities through specific examples and a genuine enthusiasm for their craft.

How can I assess a candidate’s technical skills during an interview?

Ask them to describe their techniques in detail, provide examples of their work, and consider a practical assessment. Observe their attention to detail, precision, and ability to handle different hair types and styles.

What are some common mistakes hairdressers make?

Overpromising results, ignoring client concerns, failing to stay up-to-date on trends, and lacking attention to detail are common mistakes. Look for candidates who are aware of these pitfalls and have strategies for avoiding them.

How can I ensure a candidate is a good fit for my salon’s culture?

Ask them about their previous work experiences, their preferred work environment, and their values as a hairdresser. Observe their interactions with other staff members and their overall demeanor to assess their cultural fit.

What are some red flags to watch out for during a practical assessment?

Poor hygiene, sloppy technique, disregard for client comfort, and failure to follow instructions are major red flags. Observe their attention to detail, precision, and ability to handle different hair types and styles.

How can I improve my salon’s hiring process to attract top talent?

Offer competitive compensation and benefits, create a positive and supportive work environment, and promote your salon’s unique culture and values. Highlight opportunities for growth and development and showcase your salon’s commitment to excellence.

Should I ask about a candidate’s social media presence?

Yes, reviewing a candidate’s social media can provide insights into their professionalism, creativity, and client interactions. Look for a portfolio showcasing their work and positive engagement with clients.

What kind of questions should I ask about their experience with color?

Ask about their experience with different coloring techniques, their knowledge of color theory, and how they handle color corrections. Ask them for specific examples of successful color transformations.

How important is it for a hairdresser to have a clientele?

Having an established clientele can be a bonus, as it shows they are capable of building relationships and retaining customers. However, focus on skills and attitude, as clientele can be built over time.

What are the legal considerations when hiring a hairdresser?

Ensure you comply with all relevant labor laws, including minimum wage requirements, anti-discrimination laws, and workplace safety regulations. Consult with an HR professional or legal advisor to ensure compliance.

How can I verify a candidate’s credentials and licenses?

Contact the relevant licensing board in your state or region to verify their credentials and ensure they are in good standing. Ask for copies of their licenses and certifications for your records.

What are some good follow-up questions to ask after the initial interview?

Ask for references from previous employers or clients, request a portfolio of their work, and consider a second interview to delve deeper into their skills and experience. Use these follow-up steps to validate your initial impressions.

---

More Hairdresser resources

Browse more posts and templates for Hairdresser: Hairdresser