Fraud Investigator Performance Review Examples: Ace Your Next Review

Performance reviews can be stressful, but they’re also a chance to showcase your value as a Fraud Investigator. This isn’t a generic performance review guide. This is about providing you with concrete examples, phrases, and frameworks you can use today to demonstrate your impact, even if your current review process feels vague or subjective.

What you’ll walk away with

• A performance review self-assessment template with weighted criteria to objectively score your contributions.
• Copy-and-paste phrases for articulating your achievements related to risk mitigation, cost savings, and stakeholder management.
• A ‘proof packet’ checklist to gather compelling evidence (metrics, artifacts, testimonials) to support your claims.
• A framework for quantifying the impact of your investigations, even when direct ROI is difficult to measure.
• A script for discussing areas for improvement in a way that showcases your self-awareness and commitment to growth.
• A plan to proactively collect feedback from stakeholders throughout the year, not just during review season.

What this is / What this isn’t

• This is: About providing tangible examples and frameworks for your Fraud Investigator performance review.
• This isn’t: A general guide to performance reviews, or a way to inflate your accomplishments.

What a hiring manager scans for in 15 seconds

Hiring managers quickly scan performance reviews for evidence of impact, ownership, and a proactive approach to problem-solving. They’re looking for more than just task completion; they want to see how you’ve contributed to the bottom line and managed risk effectively.

• Quantifiable results: Cost savings, fraud loss reduction, recovery rates.
• Risk mitigation: Prevented losses, identified vulnerabilities, improved controls.
• Stakeholder collaboration: Improved communication, built consensus, resolved conflicts.
• Process improvement: Streamlined workflows, automated tasks, increased efficiency.
• Proactive approach: Identified emerging threats, implemented preventative measures, stayed ahead of the curve.

The mistake that quietly kills candidates

Vague statements without supporting evidence are a major red flag. Saying you “improved fraud detection” is meaningless without specific metrics and examples. Back up your claims with data, artifacts, and stakeholder testimonials.

Use this when you need to showcase quantifiable results:
“Reduced fraudulent transactions by 15% in Q3 2023, resulting in a cost savings of $50,000. This was achieved by implementing a new rule-based system that flagged high-risk transactions based on [specific criteria].”

Performance review self-assessment template

Objectively score your contributions using a weighted self-assessment template. This helps you identify your strengths and weaknesses and prepare for a constructive conversation with your manager.

Here are the key criteria to include:

1. Risk Mitigation (30%): How effectively did you identify, assess, and mitigate fraud risks?
2. Cost Savings (25%): What was the financial impact of your investigations and preventative measures?
3. Stakeholder Management (20%): How effectively did you collaborate with stakeholders to achieve common goals?
4. Process Improvement (15%): Did you identify and implement improvements to fraud detection and prevention processes?
5. Professional Development (10%): Did you participate in training, mentoring, or other activities to enhance your skills?

Copy-and-paste phrases for articulating achievements

Use these phrases to clearly and concisely communicate your accomplishments. Tailor them to your specific situation and back them up with evidence.

• “Identified and mitigated [specific fraud risk], preventing an estimated loss of $[amount].”
• “Led the investigation of [complex fraud scheme], resulting in the recovery of $[amount] in stolen assets.”
• “Collaborated with [stakeholder] to implement [new control], reducing the incidence of [fraud type] by [percentage].”
• “Streamlined the [fraud detection process], reducing processing time by [percentage] and improving efficiency.”
• “Developed and delivered training on [fraud prevention topic] to [audience], increasing awareness and reducing vulnerability.”

‘Proof packet’ checklist: Gather compelling evidence

A ‘proof packet’ is a collection of artifacts and metrics that demonstrate your value. Start collecting evidence early and update it regularly.

1. Metrics: Fraud loss reduction, recovery rates, cost savings, efficiency gains.
2. Artifacts: Investigation reports, policy documents, training materials, presentations.
3. Stakeholder testimonials: Emails, letters, or quotes from stakeholders who have benefited from your work.
4. Project documentation: Project plans, status reports, meeting minutes.
5. Performance reviews: Previous performance reviews, commendations, awards.

Quantifying the impact of your investigations

Even when direct ROI is difficult to measure, you can still quantify the impact of your investigations. Focus on the potential losses prevented, the risks mitigated, and the improvements made to controls.

Here’s a framework:

1. Identify the potential loss: What was the potential financial impact of the fraud scheme?
2. Estimate the probability of the loss: What was the likelihood that the fraud scheme would succeed?
3. Calculate the expected loss: Multiply the potential loss by the probability of the loss.
4. Measure the impact of your investigation: How did your investigation reduce the potential loss or the probability of the loss?

Script for discussing areas for improvement

Discussing areas for improvement is an opportunity to showcase your self-awareness and commitment to growth. Be honest, specific, and proactive.

Use this when addressing a weakness:
“I recognize that my [specific skill] could be stronger. I’m currently working on improving this by [specific actions], and I expect to see results within [timeframe]. I’m also open to feedback and suggestions on how I can further develop this area.”

Proactively collect feedback from stakeholders

Don’t wait for your formal performance review to get feedback. Proactively solicit feedback from stakeholders throughout the year.

1. Identify key stakeholders: Who are the people who are most impacted by your work?
2. Schedule regular check-ins: Meet with stakeholders on a regular basis to discuss their needs and expectations.
3. Ask for specific feedback: What are you doing well? What could you improve?
4. Document the feedback: Keep a record of the feedback you receive and the actions you take in response.

Language bank: Phrases that signal competence

Use these phrases to demonstrate your understanding of fraud investigation best practices.

• “We need to implement a more robust risk assessment process to identify emerging threats.”
• “I recommend conducting a thorough review of our internal controls to ensure compliance with regulatory requirements.”
• “It’s important to collaborate with law enforcement to prosecute fraudsters and deter future criminal activity.”
• “We should leverage data analytics to identify patterns and anomalies that may indicate fraudulent activity.”

Quiet red flags in performance reviews

Hiring managers are alert to these subtle warning signs in performance reviews:

• Over-reliance on team accomplishments: Not clearly demonstrating your individual contributions.
• Blaming external factors for failures: Avoiding personal accountability.
• Lack of specific examples: Relying on vague generalizations instead of concrete evidence.
• Inability to articulate areas for improvement: Appearing defensive or unwilling to learn.

Contrarian truth: It’s not about perfection

Most people try to present a flawless image in their performance reviews. However, hiring managers actually appreciate honesty and self-awareness. Admitting mistakes and demonstrating how you learned from them is a stronger signal of competence than pretending to be perfect.

What strong looks like: A performance review checklist

A strong performance review demonstrates impact, ownership, and a proactive approach to problem-solving. Use this checklist to ensure your review hits the mark.

1. Quantifiable results: Include specific metrics to demonstrate your impact.
2. Concrete examples: Back up your claims with real-world examples.
3. Stakeholder testimonials: Include feedback from stakeholders who have benefited from your work.
4. Clear articulation of accomplishments: Use concise and impactful language.
5. Honest self-assessment: Acknowledge areas for improvement and demonstrate a commitment to growth.
6. Proactive approach: Show that you take initiative and are always looking for ways to improve.

FAQ

How can I quantify the impact of my investigations when there’s no direct financial loss?

Focus on the potential losses prevented, the risks mitigated, and the improvements made to controls. Estimate the potential financial impact of the fraud scheme and the likelihood that it would succeed. Then, measure how your investigation reduced the potential loss or the probability of the loss. For example, if you identified a vulnerability that could have led to a $100,000 loss with a 50% probability, preventing that loss would be worth $50,000.

What if I don’t have any metrics to support my claims?

Start collecting metrics now. Track your progress and document your results. Even if you don’t have historical data, you can still estimate the impact of your work based on industry benchmarks or expert opinions. For example, if you implemented a new fraud detection system, you can estimate the percentage reduction in fraudulent transactions based on the experiences of other companies that have implemented similar systems.

How can I get stakeholders to provide feedback?

Make it easy for them to provide feedback. Schedule regular check-ins, ask specific questions, and offer to provide them with updates on your progress. You can also use surveys or online feedback forms to collect feedback anonymously. For example, after completing an investigation, send a short survey to the stakeholders involved asking them about their satisfaction with the process and the results.

What if my manager doesn’t value my contributions?

Focus on the facts and present your case in a clear and concise manner. Back up your claims with evidence and demonstrate the value that you bring to the organization. If your manager still doesn’t appreciate your contributions, consider seeking out a new manager or a new role where your skills are more valued.

How do I handle negative feedback in my performance review?

Listen carefully to the feedback and try to understand the perspective of the person giving it. Don’t get defensive or try to make excuses. Acknowledge the feedback and express your willingness to learn and improve. Then, develop a plan to address the areas for improvement and track your progress. For example, if you receive feedback that you need to improve your communication skills, you can take a communication course or ask a colleague to provide you with feedback on your emails and presentations.

What are some common mistakes to avoid in performance reviews?

Avoid vague statements, lack of supporting evidence, blaming external factors, and inability to articulate areas for improvement. Also, avoid comparing yourself to others or making excuses for your performance. Focus on your own accomplishments and demonstrate the value that you bring to the organization.

How can I prepare for my performance review?

Review your job description and identify the key responsibilities and performance expectations. Then, gather evidence to demonstrate how you have met or exceeded those expectations. Also, identify areas where you could improve and develop a plan to address those areas. Finally, practice your presentation and be prepared to answer questions from your manager.

What should I do if I disagree with my performance review?

Schedule a meeting with your manager to discuss your concerns. Be prepared to present your case in a clear and concise manner, and back up your claims with evidence. If you are still unable to reach an agreement, you may have the option to appeal the review to a higher authority. However, it’s important to weigh the potential benefits of appealing the review against the potential risks of damaging your relationship with your manager.

How important are metrics in a performance review?

Metrics are crucial. They provide tangible evidence of your impact and allow your manager to objectively assess your performance. Without metrics, it’s difficult to demonstrate the value that you bring to the organization.

What if I’m new to the role and don’t have a lot of accomplishments to show?

Focus on your contributions to the team, your willingness to learn, and your commitment to improving your skills. Also, highlight any successes you have had in previous roles that are relevant to your current position. For example, if you have experience in data analysis, you can highlight how you have used those skills to improve fraud detection processes in your current role.

How can I make my performance review stand out from the crowd?

Focus on the value that you bring to the organization and demonstrate how you have made a positive impact on the bottom line. Also, be proactive in identifying and addressing areas for improvement. Finally, be enthusiastic and passionate about your work.

What is the best way to document my accomplishments throughout the year?

Create a ‘proof packet’ and update it regularly. Include metrics, artifacts, stakeholder testimonials, project documentation, and performance reviews. Store your ‘proof packet’ in a secure location and make it easily accessible to your manager.

---

More Fraud Investigator resources

Browse more posts and templates for Fraud Investigator: Fraud Investigator