What to Ask in Week 1 as an Executive Chef

Stepping into a new Executive Chef role is like inheriting a complex dish mid-service. You need to quickly assess the ingredients, the equipment, and the team before you can start plating. This guide gives you the critical questions to ask in your first week, so you can diagnose the kitchen’s health, identify potential bottlenecks, and start building a winning menu. This isn’t about generic onboarding; this is about diving into the specifics of *this* kitchen and *this* role.

The Promise: A Week 1 Diagnostic Toolkit

By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear plan for your first week as an Executive Chef. You’ll be armed with specific questions to ask, a rubric to evaluate the answers, and a checklist to ensure you cover all critical areas. This is not about becoming a culinary expert overnight, but about identifying key areas for improvement and building a solid foundation for success. You’ll be able to immediately apply these tools to understand the existing operations, prioritize your efforts, and set realistic expectations for your team and stakeholders.

• A 30-question diagnostic checklist to uncover hidden issues in the kitchen.
• A stakeholder interview script to gather crucial insights from key team members.
• A kitchen assessment rubric to objectively evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the operation.
• A priority matrix to focus on the most impactful areas for improvement.
• A communication plan template to keep everyone informed about your progress.
• A 7-day action plan template to structure your initial efforts effectively.

What You’ll Walk Away With

• A 30-question diagnostic checklist: Ready to uncover hidden issues and operational inefficiencies.
• A stakeholder interview script: Ensuring you gather crucial insights from your team.
• A kitchen assessment rubric: Objectively evaluating strengths and weaknesses.
• A priority matrix: Focusing on the most impactful improvements.
• A communication plan template: Keeping everyone informed and aligned.
• A 7-day action plan template: Structuring your initial efforts for maximum impact.

The 30-Question Diagnostic Checklist for Executive Chefs

Your first week is about listening, not lecturing. Use this checklist to understand the current state of the kitchen, identify pain points, and build relationships. This isn’t about judging; it’s about gathering information to make informed decisions.

1. What are the restaurant’s peak service times and days? Understanding peak demand helps optimize staffing and inventory.
2. What is the average cover count during peak hours? Provides insights into kitchen capacity and potential bottlenecks.
3. What is the current food cost percentage? A critical metric for profitability and efficiency.
4. What is the average plate cost? Helps analyze menu pricing and profitability.
5. What are the most popular menu items? Identifies revenue drivers and customer preferences.
6. What are the least popular menu items? Highlights areas for menu optimization and potential waste reduction.
7. What is the current inventory management system? Understanding inventory practices helps prevent shortages and reduce waste.
8. What is the waste percentage? Identifies areas for improvement in food handling and portion control.
9. What is the current supplier network? Assesses the reliability and quality of suppliers.
10. What are the contract terms with the key suppliers? Understanding contract terms helps negotiate better deals and manage costs.
11. What is the frequency of deliveries from suppliers? Optimizes delivery schedules to minimize storage needs and ensure freshness.
12. What is the kitchen’s current layout and equipment condition? Identifies potential bottlenecks and equipment maintenance needs.
13. What is the staffing level for each shift? Determines if staffing is adequate to meet demand.
14. What is the average employee turnover rate? Highlights potential issues with employee satisfaction and retention.
15. What is the current training program for kitchen staff? Assesses the effectiveness of training and identifies areas for improvement.
16. What is the kitchen’s current cleaning and sanitation schedule? Ensures compliance with health and safety regulations.
17. What is the procedure for handling food safety incidents? Assesses the kitchen’s preparedness for food safety emergencies.
18. What are the current health inspection scores? Provides insights into the kitchen’s compliance with health regulations.
19. What is the customer feedback mechanism? Understanding customer feedback helps identify areas for improvement in food quality and service.
20. What are the most common customer complaints? Addresses recurring issues and improves customer satisfaction.
21. What is the kitchen’s current budget for food and labor? Understanding budget constraints helps prioritize spending and manage costs.
22. What are the key performance indicators (KPIs) used to measure kitchen performance? Aligns kitchen operations with overall business goals.
23. What is the process for menu development and costing? Helps create profitable and innovative menu items.
24. What are the current marketing and promotional strategies for the restaurant? Aligns kitchen operations with marketing efforts.
25. What is the communication flow between the kitchen and the front-of-house staff? Ensures smooth service and accurate order fulfillment.
26. What is the process for handling special dietary requests? Accommodates customer needs and enhances customer satisfaction.
27. What is the kitchen’s current energy consumption and waste management practices? Identifies opportunities for cost savings and environmental sustainability.
28. What is the kitchen’s current pest control program? Ensures compliance with health and safety regulations.
29. What is the kitchen’s current system for tracking and managing food allergies? Protects customers with allergies and ensures compliance with regulations.
30. What is the leadership style of key members in the kitchen? Understanding leadership styles will help you better communicate with the team and set better expectations.

Stakeholder Interview Script: Uncovering Hidden Insights

Don’t rely solely on your observations. Talk to your team, the front-of-house staff, and even key suppliers. Their perspectives are invaluable.

Use this script to guide your conversations and gather consistent data points:

Executive Chef: “Thanks for meeting with me. I’m trying to get a handle on how things work here. What do you think are the three biggest challenges facing the kitchen right now?”

Executive Chef: “What are the three things that are working really well?”

Executive Chef: “If you could change one thing about the kitchen, what would it be?”

Executive Chef: “What are your biggest frustrations with the current processes?”

Executive Chef: “What is the best thing about working in this kitchen?”

Executive Chef: “What do you need from me to be successful?”

Kitchen Assessment Rubric: Objectively Evaluating the Operation

Subjectivity is the enemy of improvement. Use this rubric to evaluate the kitchen’s performance across key areas. Assign scores based on your observations and the information you gathered from the diagnostic checklist and stakeholder interviews.

Use this rubric to guide your assessment and identify areas for improvement:

Criteria: Food Quality, Food Cost, Staffing, Equipment, Cleanliness, Customer Satisfaction

Rating Scale: 1 (Poor) to 5 (Excellent)

Example:

Criteria: Food Quality

Rating: 3

Justification: “Food quality is inconsistent, with some dishes exceeding expectations while others fall short. Customer feedback indicates a need for improved flavor profiles and presentation.”

Priority Matrix: Focusing on the Most Impactful Improvements

You can’t fix everything at once. Use this matrix to prioritize your efforts based on the potential impact and the effort required. Focus on the quick wins first to build momentum and credibility.

Use this matrix to guide your prioritization and focus on the most impactful areas:

Quadrant 1: High Impact, Low Effort (Quick Wins)

Quadrant 2: High Impact, High Effort (Major Projects)

Quadrant 3: Low Impact, Low Effort (Fillers)

Quadrant 4: Low Impact, High Effort (Avoid)

Example:

Improve Food Quality: High Impact, High Effort

Streamline Inventory Management: High Impact, Low Effort

Communication Plan Template: Keeping Everyone Informed and Aligned

Transparency is key to building trust and support. Use this template to communicate your findings, your priorities, and your progress to your team, your superiors, and other stakeholders.

Use this template to guide your communication and keep everyone informed:

Audience: Team, Superiors, Stakeholders

Message: Findings, Priorities, Progress

Frequency: Daily, Weekly, Monthly

Channels: Meetings, Emails, Reports

Example:

Audience: Team

Message: “Here are the key areas we will be focusing on this week.”

Frequency: Daily

Channels: Meeting

7-Day Action Plan Template: Structuring Your Initial Efforts Effectively

Structure is essential to success. Use this template to plan your activities for each day of your first week. Focus on gathering information, building relationships, and identifying quick wins.

Use this template to guide your actions and structure your initial efforts:

Day 1: Meet with key staff, review financial reports, and complete a kitchen walkthrough.

Day 2: Conduct stakeholder interviews, analyze customer feedback, and assess inventory management practices.

Day 3: Evaluate equipment condition, review cleaning and sanitation schedules, and assess food safety procedures.

Day 4: Develop a priority matrix, create a communication plan, and identify quick wins.

Day 5: Implement quick wins, communicate progress to stakeholders, and plan for major projects.

FAQ

What if the kitchen is in complete disarray?

Focus on the most critical areas first, such as food safety and sanitation. Implement immediate improvements to address these issues and prevent potential health hazards. In a situation where the kitchen is in disarray, it’s best to document everything, take pictures, and inform your direct manager so you have the support you need to fix the problems.

What if the staff is resistant to change?

Build trust and rapport with the staff by listening to their concerns and involving them in the improvement process. Communicate the benefits of the changes and provide training and support to help them adapt. Change is always hard. It is even harder when the people on the ground aren’t involved in the discussion.

What if I don’t have all the answers?

Be honest and transparent with your team and stakeholders. Acknowledge your limitations and seek input from others. It’s better to admit you don’t know something than to provide inaccurate information. The best thing to do is to find the answer and then pass it along.

What if I make a mistake?

Own up to your mistakes and learn from them. Use them as opportunities to improve your processes and prevent future errors. Everyone makes mistakes. It is important to show your team that you can admit when you are wrong.

What if I’m overwhelmed by the amount of work?

Break down the work into smaller, manageable tasks and prioritize them based on their impact and urgency. Delegate tasks to your team members and seek assistance from your superiors. It is important to take care of yourself, so be sure to step away and take a break when things get overwhelming.

How do I get buy-in from the front-of-house staff?

Meet with the front-of-house staff to understand their needs and concerns. Communicate the improvements you are making in the kitchen to enhance their service and customer satisfaction. The front-of-house staff is your eyes and ears. Be sure to listen to their advice and concerns.

What metrics should I track in the first week?

Focus on the most critical KPIs, such as food cost percentage, waste percentage, and customer satisfaction scores. Track these metrics daily or weekly to monitor your progress and identify areas for improvement. As a chef, you are a business person, so it is important to track the key metrics.

How do I build relationships with suppliers?

Meet with your key suppliers to understand their operations and build a strong working relationship. Negotiate better deals and ensure timely deliveries of high-quality ingredients. Suppliers are key to your success. Be sure to treat them with respect and build a strong relationship.

How do I handle difficult stakeholders?

Listen to their concerns and address them with empathy and professionalism. Communicate your findings and recommendations clearly and concisely, and seek their input and support. It is important to remember that you are working towards a common goal, so try to find common ground.

What are some common mistakes new Executive Chefs make in their first week?

Ignoring the existing team, making sweeping changes without understanding the current state, and failing to communicate effectively are common pitfalls. Take the time to listen, learn, and build relationships before implementing major changes. It’s easy to come in and try to fix everything at once, but it’s important to take a measured approach.

What are quiet red flags I should be looking for?

Dishonest answers or a lack of knowledge from the staff, signs of poor hygiene, or a disorganized kitchen are all cause for concern. If you see any of these red flags, take immediate action to address them and prevent potential problems. The kitchen is a reflection of the chef. If the kitchen is dirty, it’s a sign that the chef isn’t paying attention.

What if the previous Executive Chef left on bad terms?

Acknowledge the situation and focus on building a positive and supportive environment. Avoid criticizing the previous chef and focus on the future. The past is the past. It’s important to focus on the future and not dwell on what happened before you arrived.

---

More Executive Chef resources

Browse more posts and templates for Executive Chef: Executive Chef