Red Flags in Copywriter Interviews: Spotting the Fakers

You’re interviewing Copywriter, but how do you separate the wordsmiths from the word-salad slingers? This isn’t about generic interview tips; it’s about the specific red flags that scream “don’t hire” when you’re looking for a Copywriter who can actually drive results. We’re focusing on the signals that separate the candidates who look good on paper from those who can actually deliver effective copy.

The Promise: Avoid Costly Hiring Mistakes

By the end of this article, you’ll have a concrete toolkit to avoid costly hiring mistakes: (1) a checklist to use during Copywriter interviews, (2) a scorecard to use after, and (3) a script for pushing back on candidates who try to BS their way through technical questions. This isn’t a guide to being a “nice” interviewer; it’s about protecting your budget and your brand.

• Interview Checklist: A 20+ point checklist to flag potential problems during the interview.
• Interview Scorecard: A weighted scoring system to objectively rank candidates based on specific Copywriter skills.
• Pushback Script: Exact wording to challenge vague answers and uncover true expertise.
• Red Flag Library: A list of common red flags and what they reveal about a candidate’s abilities.
• Scenario Questions: Questions designed to expose a candidate’s ability to handle real-world Copywriter challenges.
• Artifact Requests: What specific work samples to ask for to gauge their skill level.

What You’ll Walk Away With

• A 20+ point checklist to use during the interview.
• A weighted scorecard to evaluate candidates objectively.
• A pushback script to challenge vague answers.
• A red flag library to quickly identify potential problems.
• Scenario questions to test real-world problem-solving skills.
• Artifact requests to assess practical skills.

What this is / What this isn’t

• This IS: A guide to spotting red flags in Copywriter interviews.
• This IS NOT: A general guide to interviewing.

What a hiring manager scans for in 15 seconds

Hiring managers want to quickly assess if a candidate understands the realities of a Copywriter role. They’re looking for specific keywords, quantifiable results, and evidence of real-world experience. They want to see if the candidate can communicate clearly and concisely, and if they understand the importance of data-driven decision-making.

• Portfolio quality: Are the samples relevant and impactful?
• Industry experience: Do they understand the target audience and market?
• Communication skills: Can they articulate their ideas clearly and persuasively?
• Problem-solving abilities: Can they identify and solve complex problems?
• Data-driven mindset: Do they use data to inform their decisions and measure results?

The mistake that quietly kills candidates

The biggest mistake is failing to provide concrete examples of their work and its impact. Candidates often talk about their skills in abstract terms, without providing any evidence to back up their claims. This makes it difficult for hiring managers to assess their true abilities and determine if they’re a good fit for the role. This is lethal because it suggests the candidate either lacks experience or doesn’t understand the importance of quantifying their work.

Red Flag #1: Vague Answers and Buzzword Bingo

A candidate who relies on buzzwords and avoids specifics is likely hiding a lack of real-world experience. A strong Copywriter can explain complex concepts in simple terms and provide concrete examples of their work. If they can’t, it’s a red flag.

The pushback script:

Use this when a candidate gives a vague answer.

Interviewer: “Can you tell me about a time you improved conversion rates with your copy?”
Candidate: “I’m very results-oriented and I always strive to create engaging content that resonates with the target audience.”
Interviewer: “That’s great, but can you give me a specific example? What were the conversion rates before and after, and what specific changes did you make to the copy?”

Red Flag #2: No Portfolio or Irrelevant Samples

A Copywriter without a portfolio is like a chef without a kitchen. If they can’t show you their work, they’re probably not a real Copywriter. And if their portfolio is full of irrelevant samples (e.g., blog posts when you need website copy), it’s a sign they don’t understand your needs.

Red Flag #3: Lack of Industry Knowledge

A Copywriter who doesn’t understand your industry is going to struggle to create effective copy. They need to understand the target audience, the competitive landscape, and the specific challenges and opportunities facing your business. If they can’t demonstrate this knowledge, it’s a red flag.

Red Flag #4: Inability to Quantify Results

A Copywriter who can’t quantify their results is flying blind. They need to be able to track their performance, measure their impact, and use data to inform their decisions. If they can’t tell you how their copy has improved conversion rates, increased sales, or generated leads, it’s a red flag.

Red Flag #5: Poor Communication Skills

A Copywriter with poor communication skills is going to be a nightmare to work with. They need to be able to communicate clearly and concisely, both in writing and in person. If they can’t articulate their ideas effectively, it’s a red flag.

Red Flag #6: No Understanding of SEO

In today’s world, a Copywriter who doesn’t understand SEO is a dinosaur. They need to understand keyword research, on-page optimization, and how to write copy that ranks well in search engines. Otherwise, you’re paying them to write copy that no one will ever see.

Red Flag #7: Unwillingness to Take Feedback

A Copywriter who is resistant to feedback is going to be difficult to manage and will likely produce subpar work. They need to be open to constructive criticism and willing to make changes based on feedback. If they’re defensive or argumentative, it’s a red flag.

Red Flag #8: No Questions to Ask

A candidate who doesn’t ask questions is either unprepared or uninterested. A good Copywriter will be curious about your business, your target audience, and your specific needs. If they don’t have any questions, it’s a red flag.

The Interview Checklist: Spotting the Problems in Real-Time

Use this checklist during the interview to quickly identify potential red flags. Don’t wait until after the interview to realize you missed something important.

Use this checklist during the interview.

1. Does the candidate have a portfolio?
2. Are the portfolio samples relevant to your needs?
3. Can the candidate explain their work clearly and concisely?
4. Can the candidate quantify their results?
5. Does the candidate understand your industry?
6. Does the candidate understand SEO?
7. Is the candidate open to feedback?
8. Does the candidate ask thoughtful questions?
9. Does the candidate seem genuinely interested in the role?
10. Does the candidate avoid specifics and rely on buzzwords?
11. Does the candidate badmouth previous employers?
12. Does the candidate seem arrogant or entitled?
13. Does the candidate have any obvious communication problems?
14. Does the candidate seem unprepared for the interview?
15. Does the candidate have any red flags on their resume?
16. Does the candidate seem like a good fit for your company culture?
17. Does the candidate have any unrealistic salary expectations?
18. Does the candidate have any unexplained gaps in their employment history?
19. Does the candidate seem trustworthy and reliable?
20. Does the candidate have any obvious lies or exaggerations on their resume or in their answers?

The Interview Scorecard: Objectively Ranking Candidates

Use this scorecard after the interview to objectively rank candidates based on specific Copywriter skills. This will help you make a more informed hiring decision and avoid being swayed by personal biases.

Use this scorecard after the interview.

1. Portfolio Quality (30%)
2. Industry Knowledge (20%)
3. Communication Skills (20%)
4. Quantifiable Results (15%)
5. SEO Knowledge (10%)
6. Overall Fit (5%)

FAQ

What are some common mistakes Copywriter make in interviews?

Common mistakes include not having a portfolio, being unable to quantify results, lacking industry knowledge, and having poor communication skills. These mistakes suggest a lack of experience or a misunderstanding of what it takes to be a successful Copywriter.

How important is a portfolio for a Copywriter interview?

A portfolio is essential. It’s the primary way for a candidate to demonstrate their skills and experience. Without a portfolio, it’s difficult to assess their abilities and determine if they’re a good fit for the role.

What kind of questions should I ask a Copywriter during an interview?

Ask questions about their experience, their process, their results, and their understanding of your industry. Focus on questions that require them to provide specific examples and quantify their achievements.

How can I tell if a Copywriter is exaggerating their skills?

Look for vague answers, a reliance on buzzwords, and an inability to provide concrete examples. Push them to provide specific details and quantify their results. If they can’t, they’re likely exaggerating.

What are some red flags on a Copywriter resume?

Red flags include typos, grammatical errors, a lack of quantifiable results, and a focus on generic skills rather than specific achievements. These suggest a lack of attention to detail and a poor understanding of what’s important in a Copywriter role.

How important is it for a Copywriter to understand SEO?

In today’s digital landscape, SEO knowledge is crucial. A Copywriter who doesn’t understand SEO is going to struggle to create copy that ranks well in search engines and drives traffic to your website.

How can I assess a Copywriter’s communication skills during an interview?

Pay attention to how they communicate, both verbally and in writing. Are they clear, concise, and persuasive? Do they use proper grammar and spelling? Do they avoid jargon and buzzwords?

What should I look for in a Copywriter’s portfolio?

Look for relevant samples that demonstrate their ability to create effective copy for your industry. Pay attention to the quality of the writing, the clarity of the messaging, and the overall impact of the work.

How important is it for a Copywriter to be creative?

Creativity is important, but it’s not the only thing that matters. A Copywriter also needs to be strategic, analytical, and results-oriented. They need to be able to balance creativity with data-driven decision-making.

What are some common mistakes Copywriter make on their resumes?

Common mistakes include using generic language, failing to quantify results, and focusing on responsibilities rather than achievements. They should highlight their skills and experience and demonstrate their ability to drive results.

What is the best way to prepare for a Copywriter interview?

Research the company, review the job description, and prepare specific examples of your work and its impact. Practice answering common interview questions and be ready to discuss your skills, experience, and achievements.

How can I stand out from other Copywriter candidates?

Demonstrate your understanding of the company, your industry, and your target audience. Provide specific examples of your work and its impact. Highlight your skills and experience and show your passion for Copywriter.

---

More Copywriter resources

Browse more posts and templates for Copywriter: Copywriter