How to Evaluate a Activity Director Offer

So, you’ve landed an Activity Director offer. Congratulations! But before you pop the champagne, let’s make sure it’s the right one. This isn’t just about the money; it’s about the opportunity, the culture, and your long-term career trajectory. This is about evaluating the offer for you, not just accepting a paycheck. This isn’t a generic career guide; it’s a Activity Director’s playbook for making smart decisions.

The Activity Director’s Offer Evaluation Playbook

By the end of this, you’ll have a structured approach to evaluating any Activity Director offer. You’ll walk away with: (1) a scorecard to weigh different aspects of the offer, (2) a script for negotiating key terms, (3) a checklist to ensure you’ve covered all your bases, and (4) a decision framework to compare offers side-by-side. Expect to make a better, faster decision within the next week. This guide won’t tell you what to choose, but it will give you the tools to choose wisely.

• Activity Director Offer Scorecard: A weighted scorecard to objectively assess different aspects of the offer (compensation, culture, growth opportunities, etc.).
• Negotiation Script: Exact phrases to use when negotiating salary, benefits, or other terms.
• Due Diligence Checklist: A list of questions to ask during the final stages of the interview process to uncover hidden red flags.
• Decision Matrix: A framework for comparing multiple offers side-by-side.
• Red Flag Detector: A list of subtle signs that an offer might not be as good as it seems.
• Language Bank for Pushback: Phrases to use when countering low offers or unfavorable terms.

What a hiring manager scans for in 15 seconds

Hiring managers are looking for someone who understands the realities of the Activity Director role. They want to see evidence of your ability to manage budgets, timelines, and stakeholders effectively.

• Budget Management Experience: Shows you can handle financial responsibilities.
• Stakeholder Communication Skills: Indicates you can manage expectations and keep everyone aligned.
• Project Management Methodologies: Demonstrates you have a structured approach to your work.
• Problem-Solving Abilities: Highlights your ability to overcome challenges and keep projects on track.
• Risk Management Expertise: Shows you can identify and mitigate potential risks.
• Conflict Resolution Skills: Suggests you can navigate disagreements and find mutually agreeable solutions.

The mistake that quietly kills candidates

Accepting the first offer without negotiation is a mistake that quietly kills candidates. It signals a lack of confidence and understanding of your own value. Don’t leave money on the table or miss out on better benefits.

Use this when you receive an offer that is lower than expected:

“Thank you for the offer. I’m excited about the opportunity, but the salary is lower than I was expecting. Based on my research and experience, I was targeting a range of $[Target Range]. Are you able to meet me closer to that range?”

Understanding the Components of the Offer

Before you can evaluate an offer, you need to understand its components. This includes salary, benefits, equity (if applicable), and other perks.

Salary

Salary is the base compensation you’ll receive. Research the average salary for Activity Directors in your location and industry.

Benefits

Benefits can include health insurance, paid time off, retirement plans, and other perks. Consider the value of these benefits when evaluating the offer.

Equity

Equity is ownership in the company. If the company is a startup, equity can be a significant part of the compensation package.

Scoring the Offer: The Activity Director Offer Scorecard

Use this scorecard to objectively assess different aspects of the offer. Assign weights to each category based on your priorities.

Sample Scorecard Criteria:

• Compensation (40%): Salary, bonus, equity, benefits.
• Growth Opportunities (20%): Potential for advancement, training programs, mentorship opportunities.
• Company Culture (20%): Work-life balance, team environment, values.
• Role Responsibilities (10%): Alignment with your skills and interests, opportunities for challenge and growth.
• Location & Commute (10%): Proximity to your home, ease of commute.

Weigh each factor according to your priorities, then assign a score from 1-5 for each offer. Multiply the weight by the score to get a weighted score, then add up the weighted scores to get a total score.

Negotiating Key Terms

Don’t be afraid to negotiate. Most companies expect candidates to negotiate their offers.

Salary Negotiation

Know your worth and be prepared to back it up with data. Research industry benchmarks and highlight your accomplishments.

Benefits Negotiation

If the salary is non-negotiable, try negotiating for better benefits. This could include more paid time off, better health insurance, or tuition reimbursement.

Equity Negotiation

Negotiating equity can be complex. Consult with a financial advisor to understand the potential value of the equity.

Due Diligence: Asking the Right Questions

Before accepting an offer, do your due diligence. Ask questions to uncover hidden red flags.

Questions to Ask the Hiring Manager

• What are the biggest challenges facing the company/team?
• What are the company’s/team’s goals for the next year?
• What is the company’s culture like?
• What are the opportunities for growth and development?

Questions to Ask Current Employees

• What do you like most/least about working here?
• What is the work-life balance like?
• How is management perceived?
• Are there opportunities for advancement?

Red Flags to Watch Out For

Be aware of potential red flags. These could indicate problems with the company or the role.

• High employee turnover
• Negative reviews online
• Vague job description
• Lack of clarity about responsibilities
• Unrealistic expectations

Decision Matrix: Comparing Offers Side-by-Side

Create a decision matrix to compare offers side-by-side. This will help you visualize the pros and cons of each offer.

Example Decision Matrix:

List all offers and compare according to your weighted criteria.

Language Bank for Pushback

Use these phrases when countering low offers or unfavorable terms.

Use this when countering a low salary offer:

“I appreciate the offer, but based on my research and experience, I believe my market value is closer to $[Target Salary]. I’m confident that I can bring significant value to your team. Are you able to reconsider the salary?”

Use this when requesting better benefits:

“The salary is a bit lower than I expected. Would it be possible to increase the vacation time to [Number] weeks?”

The Importance of Company Culture

Company culture is a critical factor to consider. A positive culture can make a big difference in your job satisfaction and overall well-being.

Making the Final Decision

Ultimately, the decision is yours. Weigh all the factors and choose the offer that is the best fit for you.

What strong looks like

A strong Activity Director knows their value and isn’t afraid to advocate for themselves. They understand the importance of company culture and are willing to ask tough questions to uncover potential red flags.

FAQ

How do I research salary ranges for Activity Directors?

Use online resources like Glassdoor, Salary.com, and Payscale to research salary ranges for Activity Directors in your location and industry. Also, talk to other Activity Directors to get a sense of what they are earning.

What if the company won’t negotiate the salary?

If the company won’t negotiate the salary, try negotiating for better benefits, such as more paid time off, better health insurance, or tuition reimbursement. Consider if the other factors of the role (growth opportunities, company culture) outweigh the salary.

How do I handle a counteroffer from my current employer?

Carefully consider the reasons why you were looking for a new job in the first place. If the counteroffer addresses those concerns, it may be worth considering. However, be aware that accepting a counteroffer can damage your relationship with your current employer.

What are some good questions to ask during the final interview?

Ask questions about the company’s goals, the team’s challenges, and the opportunities for growth and development. Also, ask about the company’s culture and management style. What does success look like in the first 3 months? In the first year?

How important is company culture?

Company culture is very important. A positive culture can make a big difference in your job satisfaction and overall well-being. Look for a company that values its employees and has a positive work environment. Do they offer flexible work options? Do they have team-building activities?

What if I have no other offers?

Even if you have no other offers, it’s still worth negotiating. The company has already invested time and resources in interviewing you, so they are likely to be willing to negotiate to some extent. Start by asking for a higher salary or better benefits.

Should I accept an offer just because it’s the first one I received?

No, you should not accept an offer just because it’s the first one you received. Take the time to evaluate the offer carefully and compare it to other opportunities. Consider your long-term career goals and choose the offer that is the best fit for you.

What if I’m worried about appearing greedy by negotiating?

Negotiating is a normal part of the hiring process. Companies expect candidates to negotiate their offers. As long as you are respectful and professional, you should not worry about appearing greedy. Frame your negotiation as a discussion about your value and what you can bring to the company.

Is it okay to ask for a signing bonus?

Yes, it is okay to ask for a signing bonus. A signing bonus can be a good way to compensate for lost income or benefits from your previous job. It’s particularly relevant if you’re foregoing a bonus at your current employer.

How do I know if a company has a good work-life balance?

Ask current employees about their work-life balance. Also, look for companies that offer flexible work arrangements, such as remote work or flextime. Pay attention to how employees talk about their workload and whether they seem stressed or overworked.

What if the company is a startup and the salary is lower than market value?

If the company is a startup and the salary is lower than market value, consider the potential for equity and growth. If you believe in the company’s mission and see potential for significant upside, it may be worth accepting a lower salary. However, be sure to carefully evaluate the risks involved.

How do I politely decline an offer?

Thank the hiring manager for the offer and express your appreciation for their time. Briefly explain why you are declining the offer, such as that you have accepted another opportunity or that the role is not the right fit for you. Be professional and courteous in your response.

---

More Activity Director resources

Browse more posts and templates for Activity Director: Activity Director